Custom HTTP Client - Dotnet 8 and C#
A custom HTTP client is a generic HTTP client implementation that is created and configured specifically for a particular application or use case. It provides more control over the low-level details of HTTP requests and responses, allowing developers to tailor the client to their specific needs.
Comparison with other techniques is available here
How to integrate in c#
For testing and development, I will be using a dummy service provided by odata.org
This can be achieved using various approaches, but my favorite is by using IHttpClientFactory. For more about the HTTP Client factory, please visit the official Microsoft documentation.
In Program.cs or Startup.cs, add following
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
builder.Services.AddHttpClient("TripPinServiceRW",
client =>
{
client.BaseAddress = new Uri("https://services.odata.org/V4/(S(y5tuj04bxbfsxzimbxbnauqg))/TripPinServiceRW/");
});
Now in your service class add the following dependency
1
2
3
4
5
6
public class MyCustomDummyService(IHttpClientFactory httpClientFactory)
{
// Other code
}
And create a client
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
public class MyCustomDummyService(IHttpClientFactory httpClientFactory)
{
public async Task FechDummyData()
{
using var client = _httpClientFactory.CreateClient(TripPinServiceRW);
// Other Logic
}
}
Now you can just use httpclient method to fetch the data.
If you are working on a console app or something where you can’t use the dependency injections, in that case, you can just create a new instance of HttpClient and use it. you can get some code here
Advantages of Custom HttpClient
Custom HttpClient provides complete control over the underlying HTTP requests and responses, allowing for fine-grained customization and tailoring to specific OData requirements.
Direct manipulation of HTTP requests and responses can lead to optimized communication and better performance, especially for high-traffic scenarios or large data transfers.
Custom HttpClient allows developers to define custom headers and payloads for OData requests, enabling integration with specific OData service features or protocols.
Custom HttpClient can be easily integrated into existing projects, as it’s a built-in .NET component. This eliminates the need for additional dependencies or learning new libraries.
Custom HttpClient doesn’t rely on OData-specific libraries, making it more versatile and adaptable to different OData service implementations.
Disadvantages of Custom HttpClient
Implementing a custom HttpClient solution requires a deeper understanding of HTTP protocols and OData concepts, increasing the development complexity compared to using OData client libraries.
Custom HttpClient requires manual error handling, which can be time-consuming and error-prone compared to libraries that handle exceptions automatically.
Manually parsing and mapping OData responses to custom C# classes can be tedious and error-prone, especially for complex data structures.
Improper handling of HTTP requests or responses can lead to performance issues, such as inefficient data transfers or protocol violations.
Custom HttpClient is not as widely used as OData client libraries, which may mean fewer resources available for troubleshooting and support.
Use cases for custom HTTP clients
When the OData client libraries don’t provide adequate support for specific features or protocols, a custom HTTP client can be tailored to meet the requirements.
In scenarios where performance or security is critical, a custom HTTP client can be optimized for specific requirements.
A custom HTTP client can be integrated with custom middleware or logging mechanisms to handle additional tasks or collect specific data.
For experimental or research projects, a custom HTTP client allows for more flexibility and experimentation with different approaches.
Conclusion
In summary, Custom HttpClient provides maximum flexibility and control for fine-tuning OData interactions but comes with a higher development overhead and potential for errors. It’s suitable for experienced developers who need to handle specific OData requirements or integrate with non-standard OData services. For simpler scenarios or projects with limited resources, consider using OData client libraries that offer a higher level of abstraction and automatic data handling.
Other
If you want to explore your OData metadata, you can visit an open-source project created by me. By using this tool you can get the data types, enum values, and other useful information.